KezdőlapEnglishDeposit-related bin rummaging: how are cities tackling it worldwide? – what Reloop's...

Deposit-related bin rummaging: how are cities tackling it worldwide? – what Reloop’s new report shows

If you like our site, mark us as a preferred source on Google — so you’ll see our articles more often in search!

★Mark us as a preferred source

Deposit-related bin rummaging has become a talking point far beyond Budapest. On 11 November 2026, the international non-profit Reloop published its special report Searching for deposits, which examines one of the most visible side effects of deposit return systems (DRS): people searching public waste bins for refundable bottles and cans, sometimes leaving behind overturned bins, scattered litter and damaged infrastructure that cost municipalities real money. The report also discusses Hungary, but its real value lies in pulling together what works – and what does not – in managing deposit-related bin rummaging, from Australia and Ireland to the Netherlands.

In short: According to Reloop, deposit-related bin rummaging is a real but geographically concentrated problem, mainly affecting city centres, transport hubs and tourist areas. The answer is not to restrict access to deposit refunds, but to combine convenient returns, container holders on bins, donation points, harder-to-open bins and targeted communication.

How big is the problem, and where does it occur?

The report does not downplay the issue. In the Netherlands, a 2025 study estimated that bin damage and extra litter linked to deposit searching cost Amsterdam, Rotterdam, Utrecht and The Hague around €9.4 million a year combined. Dublin City Council estimated the additional staff and fleet costs at roughly €351,000 a year (almost €1,000 a day), with cumulative direct costs already reaching €857,000.

The issue has also become political. In September 2026, Lisbon’s mayor Carlos Moedas called for the immediate cancellation of Portugal’s newly launched system – we previously reported on how Portugal’s “Volta” system collected more than 10 million containers in its first two months. The report also cites Hungarian examples: the mayor of Terézváros (Budapest’s District VI) proposed temporarily suspending the national DRS, which was rejected, although the government subsequently ordered a comprehensive review of the waste management system, including concerns over bottle collection. Reloop also notes that MOHU, the Hungarian system operator, raised the possibility of ending cash refunds, while in Dublin it was suggested that refunds be limited to people with registered household waste collection contracts.

The authors warn that such restrictions would create new barriers, excluding people without bank accounts or smartphones, as well as renters, students and tourists – undermining the very accessibility on which deposit systems depend. This is worth reading alongside the Hungarian figures: Hungary returned 1.515 billion containers in the first half of 2026, and most consumers at reverse vending machines chose a store voucher.

The report stresses that the problem is unevenly distributed. During the Netherlands’ 2025 National Trash Bin Count Day, around 8% of bins surveyed in the largest cities were open or damaged, compared with just 1% in rural and suburban areas. Reloop adds that bin rummaging may be especially pronounced in the early years of a system, while return habits and infrastructure are still maturing.

Who are the collectors?

One of the report’s key messages is that container collectors are far more diverse than public debate suggests. Germany’s 2026 Pfandstudie puts the number of collectors at 1.1 million (up from 980,000 in 2021). Of these, 25% were homeless while 56% had never experienced homelessness; 40% cited environmental protection as a motivation, while others were supplementing wages (19%), pensions (20%) or government assistance (22%).

In Austria, 4% of people aged 16 and over said they collect deposit containers in public spaces – an estimated 225,000 to 228,000 people. Public attitudes are surprisingly warm: 69% of Austrian respondents expressed positive views or sympathy towards collectors, and only 2% were negative. In Stockholm, a study of 21 collectors found that 90% had started collecting because they had no other legal way to earn money.

There is a health dimension too. In Montréal, 48% of collectors had been injured while collecting, and in Germany one in three collectors reported an injury, while one in two felt disgust at reaching into bins. Reloop’s starting point is therefore not to exclude collectors, but to spare them from searching through mixed waste.

Convenient returns are the first line of defence

The simplest solution is to keep as many refundable containers out of public bins as possible. Comparing 38 deposit jurisdictions, Reloop found a median return rate of 85% for return-to-retail systems, 68% for hybrid systems and only 57% for systems relying on depots or redemption centres.

Even with a strong retail network, however, many people in city centres, stations and tourist districts still bin their empties: tourists may not know the local system, and commuters may not bother seeking out a machine for a single can. This is where public-space solutions come in.

Deposit-related bin rummaging: do bin attachments work?

Deposit rings – known by their original German name Pfandring, or as bin baskets, cradles or holders – are fitted to bins, lamp posts or railings. The idea is simple: people who do not intend to redeem a container leave it in the holder rather than in the bin, where someone else can take it without rummaging.

The strongest evidence comes from New South Wales, Australia. Scheme coordinator Exchange for Change trialled bin baskets in two councils in early 2025, recording reductions of 82.5% in Eurobodalla Shire and around 50% in Sutherland Shire in eligible containers ending up in general waste bins. The first statewide round eventually involved 31 councils, with more than 1,200 baskets and nearly 60 cradles. Quantitative audits by nine councils found an average reduction of 69% (ranging from 47% to 85%). Bega Valley Shire recorded an 83% reduction; its first 20 baskets cost roughly AUD 2,000, and only one had to be replaced due to vandalism.

In Dublin, the city council and Irish DRS operator Re-turn fitted surrounds to 80 of the city centre’s roughly 600 bins in October 2024. Re-turn’s research found containers placed in the surrounds were collected within 16 minutes on average, and 79% of the public supported such schemes. More detailed 2026 research also revealed the limits: while 60% of consumers were aware of the surrounds, only 25% had used them, and people continued searching bins – including at locations with surrounds.

Why do holders often look empty?

Deposit rings remain controversial. Vienna has repeatedly rejected them, and other municipalities have ended pilots after finding the holders underused, misused or ineffective. Reloop accepts these are legitimate concerns, but points to methodological weaknesses in many evaluations.

In Almere, the Netherlands, 16 rings were checked 383 times in 2024 and were empty in 84% of observations – yet containers placed in them typically disappeared before the next check, about two hours later. An empty holder, in other words, is not necessarily an unused one. Portland, Oregon faced a similar dilemma in its 2026 audit: side-bins held an average of 0.39 deposit containers versus 2.64 inside the main bins, and the city could not say whether this reflected fast collection or low use.

The report calls this the “denominator problem”: in a very mature system such as Germany’s, which returns more than 96% of covered containers, few refundable containers reach public bins in the first place, so even an effective holder will capture only a few. Contamination can also be addressed by design: Berlin redesigned its early collection boxes after they were used as waste bins, and later designs use narrower openings and clearer signage.

Reloop argues that instead of asking whether rings “work”, evaluators should define what they want to measure. It suggests five outcomes: capture (are containers placed in holders?), recovery (are they collected?), diversion (do fewer containers enter mixed waste?), public-space impact (does rummaging or litter change?) and operational and social performance (effects on maintenance and cleaning staff and on collectors).

Dedicated bins, donations and redesigned waste bins

Beyond holders, the report presents several complementary solutions. In British Columbia, Canada, system operator Return-It provides free on-the-go collection bins to municipalities, parks and event organisers, while in Ireland Re-turn has deployed more than 5,000 orange bins at events and in communities, with proceeds supporting children’s charities.

Direct donation also works. In Vancouver, the Binners’ Project has installed more than 150 stainless-steel hooks outside homes and businesses since 2016 (CAD 20 each), where residents can hang bags of containers for collectors. In Germany, PFANDGEBEN connects donors and collectors through an app – requests are accepted within an average of 17 minutes – and has channelled around 240,000 bottles and cans, worth over €31,000 in deposits, to collectors.

Where rummaging persists, bin redesign may be needed. In February 2026, Amsterdam piloted self-closing bins with magnetic doors, reinforced interiors and separate container holders: 83% were found closed, compared with 38% of conventional bins. The city began rolling out 200 such bins in September, including at Central Station and Vondelpark. Dublin’s experience with locking compactor bins illustrates the limits of access controls: replacing locks on existing bins has already cost more than €115,000, and damage to locks continues.

Austria, Sweden and the Netherlands: local solutions

The appendices include several case studies. After Austria’s DRS launched in January 2025, Linz installed 17 deposit rings on city-centre bins for about €5,000; maintenance staff report that containers are collected regularly, misuse and vandalism are rare, and there are fewer odours and insects around bins. In Vienna, after the city rejected deposit rings, the local LINKS party began fitting crates to old bicycles – “Pfandräder” – along the Donaukanal; 13 are now in place.

Vienna also illustrates a legal paradox: leaving a container beside a bin can count as littering (with fines of €50 to €1,000), while taking containers out of municipal bins may breach waste rules, since deposited waste becomes city property. Both leaving and retrieving containers can therefore be unlawful.

In Sweden, legislation since 2022 requires system operator Returpack to provide free collection tubes (pantrör) to municipalities in public places with significant packaging waste. Each tube holds four to five containers, typically collected within about ten minutes. In the Netherlands, the Statiegeldbak developed by Studio Cantatore is now used in around 30 municipalities, including 31 units in Rotterdam, and the Dutch system operator has offered a 75% subsidy since 2026.

Lessons for new and existing systems

Reloop concludes that bin rummaging is primarily a public-space and urban waste management challenge, not evidence that a deposit system has failed. Visible city-centre problems should be weighed against the litter-reduction benefits: in Reloop’s earlier review of more than 100 jurisdictions, DRS cut beverage container litter by more than 50% on average.

The report sets out seven practical lessons:

  • Start with a pilot, with baseline data and, where possible, comparison sites without intervention.
  • Choose locations based on consumption density, not footfall alone – transport hubs, parks, event venues and nightlife districts are prime candidates.
  • Back infrastructure with awareness campaigns: in Almere, 31% of respondents did not know what the rings were for, despite explanatory stickers.
  • Review local laws so they do not make it unlawful to leave containers separately for collection.
  • Design for ease of use and maintenance, so holders do not obstruct bin emptying or cleaning.
  • Engage collectors and community organisations, who know best where and how containers accumulate.
  • Combine measures: no single tool solves the problem on its own.

These lessons are timely as several countries prepare new systems. Greece, Spain, Moldova and the United Kingdom are on the report’s list, while Türkiye has already moved past the preparation stage: its system launched on 1 July 2026 and collected 7.6 million containers in five days.

Reloop CEO and founder Clarissa Morawski argues that the goal is not to stop people recovering containers others have discarded, but to make those containers easier and safer to access while reducing pressure on public spaces and municipal services. For the Hungarian debate, this may be the key message: the mess around bins is better tackled by designing a better route for containers than by tightening access to refunds.


FAQ on deposit-related bin rummaging

What is Reloop’s Searching for deposits report?

It is a special report published by Reloop on 11 November 2026 on bin rummaging linked to deposit return systems. Drawing on international research, municipal trials and case studies, it explains why people search public bins for refundable containers, what this costs cities, and which measures – deposit rings, donation points, redesigned bins and awareness campaigns – reduce the problem.

Where is deposit-related bin rummaging most common?

It is concentrated in dense city centres, transport hubs and tourist areas with high on-the-go beverage consumption. During the Netherlands’ 2025 National Trash Bin Count Day, around 8% of bins in the largest cities were open or damaged, compared with just 1% in rural and suburban areas. The problem therefore does not affect countries evenly.

How much does bin rummaging cost municipalities?

The costs can be substantial. A 2025 Dutch study estimated that Amsterdam, Rotterdam, Utrecht and The Hague together face around €9.4 million a year in bin damage and extra litter. Dublin City Council put its additional staff and fleet costs at roughly €351,000 a year, with cumulative direct costs already reaching €857,000.

Do deposit rings and bin baskets work?

They can, when well placed and supported by communication. In New South Wales, audits by nine councils found an average 69% reduction in refundable containers entering public bins, and Bega Valley Shire recorded 83%. Other cities reported low use or contamination, so Reloop recommends pilots with baseline data and clearly defined outcome measures.

Why do deposit holders often look empty?

Because containers placed in them are often collected quickly. In Almere, the Netherlands, rings were empty in 84% of observations, yet containers typically disappeared before the next check about two hours later. In Dublin, containers were collected within 16 minutes on average. An empty holder is not necessarily unused, so visual checks alone can mislead.

Why does Reloop oppose ending cash refunds?

Because the report finds such restrictions would create new barriers to participation. Ending cash refunds could disadvantage people without bank accounts or smartphones, while tying refunds to registered waste contracts would exclude renters, students and tourists. According to Reloop, these measures undermine the accessibility and inclusiveness on which effective deposit return systems depend.


🔗 Official sources and references: 👉

Consistent structure, quick answers: every article is built so that both readers and AI search tools can find the key points easily. Our content is produced with the help of AI tools and reviewed by our editor.

Ladányi Roland
Ladányi Rolandhttp://envilove.hu
Roland Ladányi is an environmental professional and waste management expert dedicated to promoting sustainability and the circular economy. As the founder and driving force behind the dontwasteit.hu platform, he provides up-to-date news, in-depth analysis, and practical solutions aimed at shaping an environmentally conscious mindset. His work focuses on waste reduction and efficient resource management, bridging the gap between technical expertise and clear, accessible public communication.
OLVASS TOVÁBB