KezdőlapEnglishCircular economy in the process sector: IMechE warns that incentives, not technology,...

Circular economy in the process sector: IMechE warns that incentives, not technology, are holding industry back

If you like our site, mark us as a preferred source on Google — so you’ll see our articles more often in search!

★Mark us as a preferred source

The circular economy in the process sector is not being held back by a lack of engineering solutions but by the fact that it does not yet pay for companies to use them. That is the central argument of Moving to a Circular Economy in the Process Sector, a report published in November 2026 by the UK’s Institution of Mechanical Engineers (IMechE) and presented in a press release on 11 November. The engineers warn that the UK is missing a major economic opportunity unless government overhauls incentives, regulation and infrastructure.

In short: The circular economy in the process sector is, according to IMechE, primarily a systems, infrastructure and incentives problem rather than a technology problem – most solutions exist, but market forces alone will not scale them fast enough. The report asks the UK Government for three things: make reuse commercially viable, provide long-term investment certainty and build the missing infrastructure. Engineers, in turn, are asked to design for the whole life cycle from day one.

What is the report, and who is behind it?

IMechE represents 110,000 engineering professionals and students in the UK and worldwide. The report comes from the Sustainable Resources Working Group of its Process Industries Division and condenses the findings of four webinars held between February 2025 and April 2026, covering food and drink, pharmaceuticals, water, bulk handling, and upstream and downstream oil, gas and chemicals.

The process industries are defined broadly: food and drink, chemicals, pharmaceuticals, petroleum and gas, ceramics, base metals, plastics, rubber, textiles, wood and paper products, water and wastewater, and bioenergy production, among others.

In his foreword, Allan Barton, a member of the division’s board, uses a familiar estimate to frame the stakes: if all eight billion people lived like the average of the top 20 developed nations, 3.6 planets’ worth of resources would be needed. The linear take-make-dispose logic, he argues, cannot continue in the long term.

One clarification is worth making up front. The press release headline speaks of billions that a circular economy could unlock, but neither the release nor the report itself puts a figure on it. This is not an economic impact assessment; it is an expert diagnosis with a set of recommendations.

Five lessons: why the circular economy in the process sector stalls

Across very different industries, the webinar speakers arrived at the same points.

1. Circularity is a whole-system concept. The most consistent theme was the rejection of a narrow, recycling-only definition. Circularity has to cover carbon and greenhouse gases, natural ecosystems, materials, water and air quality at the same time. Focusing on a single stream risks creating problems elsewhere: waste-to-resource systems need new energy inputs, sustainable fuels create new feedstock demand, and carbon reduction measures can increase resource consumption. That requires a shared language. According to the report, inconsistent definitions of “circular” and “recyclable”, missing measurement frameworks and regulatory ambiguity are all limiting investment and cross-sector collaboration today.

2. Stewardship instead of consumption. Society still treats valuable resources as waste: phosphorus lost to waterways, disposed medicines, food waste, construction materials, carbon emissions and water itself. The report calls for economic incentives where virgin materials are cheaper than secondary ones, and for decisions based on whole-life cost rather than purchase price. The long-term goal is not only to replace new materials but to reduce the overall amount circulating in the economy. Singapore is cited as good practice: its NEWater system turns wastewater into potable water through microfiltration/ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis and UV disinfection, and can now meet more than 40 per cent of the city-state’s water needs.

3. Design decides future circularity. Whether products, plants, buildings, packaging and processes can be circular is largely determined at the design stage; retrofitting is far harder and more expensive. The report points to recent work by the National Engineering Policy Centre (NEPC): by 2038, as much as one million kilograms of neodymium could be recovered from the magnets of decommissioned UK wind turbines – yet those magnets are not being designed for recovery, and data on the volume of critical materials used is often missing. We looked at the corporate side of the same exposure in our analysis of BCG’s report on critical mineral shortages, and at product lifetimes in our article on rethinking planned obsolescence.

4. Infrastructure lock-in. Nearly every sector named legacy assets as a barrier: water and waste systems designed for disposal rather than recovery, refineries built around fossil feedstocks, pharmaceutical facilities designed primarily around compliance. Because industrial assets last so long, today’s decisions shape outcomes for decades. Circularity also depends on shared infrastructure, and co-located clusters make by-product exchange, heat integration and economies of scale possible. As an example of adapting what already exists, the report cites Phillips 66’s Humber refinery, which produces sustainable aviation fuel for British Airways from waste feedstocks such as used cooking oil.

5. Behaviour is underestimated. Cultural and behavioural change may matter more than technological innovation, the speakers argued. Demand for convenience packaging, attitudes to food waste, reluctance to adopt new farming practices, pharmaceutical risk aversion and resistance to infrastructure development all act as brakes. A survey referenced in the report found that almost nine in ten UK adults do not know what the circular economy is. Just how decisive convenience can be was also visible in the YouGov study on the UK Deposit Return Scheme.

Six cross-cutting challenges

The report groups the barriers that cut across all sectors into six areas:

  • Economic: high capital costs, long payback periods, weak commercial incentives.
  • Regulatory: slow-moving standards, complex approvals, fragmented policy frameworks.
  • Skills: a lack of circular economy competencies and a need for systems engineers. For the European workforce angle, see our analysis of the EESC opinion on circular skills.
  • Infrastructure: legacy assets and inadequate recovery systems.
  • Data: poor measurement of resource flows and no common circularity metrics.
  • Behaviour: consumer attitudes, industry risk aversion, organisational inertia, and missing or misleading information.

Sector by sector: challenges and opportunities

  • Food and drink: roughly $1 trillion of food value is lost worldwide every year; consumer expectations about appearance and convenience, packaging waste and supply-chain inefficiencies add to the problem. Opportunities include regenerative agriculture, better food redistribution, packaging redesign, deposit return schemes, anaerobic digestion and by-product utilisation.
  • Pharmaceuticals: strict regulatory controls, product safety and contamination risks, long development cycles. Opportunities include continuous manufacturing, packaging redesign, reverse logistics for medicine returns and data-driven monitoring – the last of which we covered in our article on the pharmaceutical digital product passport.
  • Water: river pollution, scarcity, ageing infrastructure and public undervaluation of water. Opportunities include water reuse, nutrient recovery, nature-based solutions and heat recovery from wastewater.
  • Bulk materials, cement and fertilisers: high energy intensity and emissions, dependence on virgin materials. Opportunities include cement reactivation, recovered phosphorus and sewage-derived nutrients, green ammonia and industrial symbiosis.
  • Oil, gas and chemicals: dependence on hydrocarbons, price volatility, transition costs and policy uncertainty. Opportunities include carbon capture and storage, sustainable aviation fuels, green hydrogen, electrification and repurposing existing infrastructure. How much of the chemical industry’s carbon demand recycling covers today is the subject of our piece on the Carbon Flows report.

Three asks of the UK Government

One of the report’s key messages is that market forces alone will not deliver the pace of change required, so government intervention is necessary. The recommendations fall into three groups.

Long-term certainty, backed by data. Stable, multi-decade signals are needed to drive investment in circular infrastructure. The forthcoming UK Circular Economy Strategy should be accompanied by clear carbon pricing trajectories, stable regulation, nationally recognised indicators, clearer definitions, harmonised standards for secondary materials and streamlined permitting for circular processes. What a carbon price can and cannot achieve on its own is something we discussed in connection with Rabobank’s analysis of CCUS at waste-to-energy plants.

Investment in infrastructure, clusters and skills. Priority should go to carbon transport networks, resource recovery hubs, water recycling infrastructure and green hydrogen systems; successful cluster models such as Teesside should be expanded; and interdisciplinary training and reskilling should be funded.

Shifting incentives and creating markets. Among the levers that could make circularity more competitive, the report lists resource taxation, extended producer responsibility, recycled content mandates and circularity requirements in public procurement. Each of these is a live debate in Europe as well: we have reported on extended producer responsibility in the context of the industry statement on the Circular Economy Act, on tax incentives for recycled content through the UK Plastic Packaging Tax, and on demand creation through circular public procurement criteria.

Kahu Te Kani, Senior Policy Advisor at IMechE, said in the release that practical opportunities already exist across industry, and that government needs to step in so that a circular economy is aligned with the UK’s Industrial Strategy and Net Zero objectives.

What is expected of engineers and their institutions?

The list for engineers is short and practical: apply whole-systems thinking, design for disassembly and reuse, consider life-cycle impacts from project inception, measure resource productivity alongside financial performance, integrate circularity into risk assessments and investment decisions, and champion evidence-based policy discussions. One item stands out – the call to fail fast, publicise failures and share what was learned.

Professional engineering institutions, the report says, should work together to provide policy leadership through joint research, standards development and convening stakeholders across sectors. Circular economy principles should also be defined more clearly as a foundational competency, for example in the Engineering Council’s guidance on sustainability.

Why this matters beyond the UK

The report is explicitly about the UK, but its diagnosis is not uniquely British. Working technologies that fail to scale because virgin material is cheaper, regulation is fragmented and payback is long is a familiar picture on the continent too, where the same instruments – producer responsibility, recycled content rules, procurement criteria – are being negotiated right now.

From a waste management perspective, the most important message is that operators at the end of the chain can only work with what designers, producers and regulators decided at the beginning. If material cannot be recovered from a product, if there is no predictable market for secondary raw materials, or if the recovery infrastructure is never built, higher recycling rates alone will not change much. IMechE’s closing thought is that the transition is not an impossible feat: many advances have already been made, but recycling and individual technologies will not be enough on their own – industrial systems, infrastructure, markets and behaviours have to be redesigned together.


Frequently asked questions – circular economy in the process sector

What does the IMechE report say about the circular economy in the process sector?

The report says the transition is primarily a systems, infrastructure and incentives problem rather than a technology problem. Most engineering solutions already exist or are emerging, but companies currently have little economic reason to adopt them. IMechE therefore concludes that market forces alone will not deliver the pace of change required and that government intervention is necessary.

Which industries does the report cover?

The report covers five areas of the process industries: food and drink, pharmaceuticals, water, bulk materials including cement and fertilisers, and upstream and downstream oil, gas and chemicals. It summarises the findings of four expert webinars held by IMechE’s Process Industries Division between February 2025 and April 2026, and notes that the conclusions may apply to other sectors too.

What barriers does the report identify?

The report identifies six cross-cutting groups of barriers: economic, regulatory, skills, infrastructure, data and behaviour. These include high capital costs and long payback periods, fragmented policy frameworks, a shortage of systems engineers, legacy assets, the lack of common circularity metrics, and consumer attitudes combined with industry risk aversion and organisational inertia.

What is IMechE asking the UK Government to do?

IMechE is asking the UK Government to take three steps. Make reuse commercially viable through resource taxation, recycled content requirements and circularity standards in public procurement. Provide long-term investment certainty through stable regulation and predictable carbon pricing. And build the infrastructure: resource recovery hubs, water recycling, carbon transport networks and industrial clusters where businesses can share resources.

Which working examples does the report mention?

The report highlights three working or achievable examples. Singapore’s NEWater system produces potable water from wastewater and can meet more than 40 per cent of the country’s water needs. Phillips 66’s Humber refinery makes sustainable aviation fuel from waste feedstocks. And up to one million kilograms of neodymium could be recovered from decommissioned UK wind turbines by 2038.

Does the report quantify the economic benefit of going circular?

No, the report does not put a figure on the economic benefit of going circular. The press release headline refers to billions, but neither the release nor the report contains an estimate to support it. The document is an expert diagnosis and a set of recommendations based on webinar findings, not an economic impact assessment; its only monetary figure concerns food value lost each year.


🔗 Official sources and references: 👉

Consistent structure, quick answers: every article is built so that both readers and AI search tools can find the key points easily. Our content is produced with the help of AI tools and reviewed by our editor.

Ladányi Roland
Ladányi Rolandhttp://envilove.hu
Roland Ladányi is an environmental professional and waste management expert dedicated to promoting sustainability and the circular economy. As the founder and driving force behind the dontwasteit.hu platform, he provides up-to-date news, in-depth analysis, and practical solutions aimed at shaping an environmentally conscious mindset. His work focuses on waste reduction and efficient resource management, bridging the gap between technical expertise and clear, accessible public communication.
OLVASS TOVÁBB